"Growth Through Knowledge"
for firms seeking Growth Capital for VC and PE firms for Listed firms

IC Tracker Online Help Page

Index

Overview Definitions Intellectual Capital Valuation Methodology FAQ


1.0 Overview

IC Tracker is the first online software that has been designed purely for measuring, tracking and reporting the Intellectual Capital of listed Companies. Over the past decade there is a growing realization worldwide that the Intellectual Capital of a company is often the competitive difference between one company and another, particularly in the same industry. However, what has been lacking has been an objective, proven and factual method of measuring and reporting Intellectual Capital. Until now!

IC Tracker measures the Intellectual Capital of companies using the Intangibles Scoreboard method explained in Intellectual Capital Valuation Methodology. This methodology has been formulated by Dr Baruch Lev and F Gu of New York University's Stern School of Business. It is widely acknowledged as a superior measure in explaining company performance. The best part of this methodology is that it uses publicly available data and allows for comparison of Intellectual Capital across Industries and over time. It can also be used to distinguish between overvalued and undervalued stocks and therefore it becomes a powerful decision making tool, especially for buy-side analysts, sell-side analysts and High NetWorth Individuals (HNIs). IC Tracker chose to use this methodology after studying and comparing it with many other valuation methodologies such as
  • Calculated Intangible Value by NCI Research
  • Economic Value AddedTM Reporting by Stern Stewart and Co.
  • iValuing Factor by Standfield
  • Options Approach based on Options Theory
  • Sullivan's work by Patrick Sullivan
  • Technology Factor by Khouri
  • Tobin's Q by James Tobin
  • Value-Added Intellectucal CoefficientTM by Pulic

Any user who is not familiar with the concept of Intellectual Capital will do well to read the entire contents of this Help page to familiarize himself with the terminology that is used in IC Tracker. Additional web links are provided on the Links page where the user can find more theoretical information about this very exciting and pertinent topic.


2.0 Definitions

Actual Stock Price Discount Rate EBITDA Forecasted Financials IC Margin IC Op Margin Intellectual Capital
Intrinsic Stock Price Intrinsic Worth K Basis Latest Stock Price Liquidity Premium Long Term Growth Market Cap
MVToIV Net Worth Past Financials PAT PBT PBDT Sales
Total Income
2.1 Intellectual Capital

Intellectual Capital in its simplest form refers to all the intangible capital of a company. However it is a term that has been defined differently by different authors who are considered experts in this field.

  • Brooking (1996) defines it as "the combined intangible assets, which enable the company to function."
  • Stewart (1997) defines it as "packaged useful knowledge".
  • Roos et al. (1997) defines it as the "sum of the knowledge of its members and the practical translation of this knowledge into brands, trademarks and processes."
  • Edvinsson and Malone (1997) define it as "the possession of the knowledge, applied existence, organizational technology, customer relationship and professional skills that provide a company with competitive edge in the market."
  • Sveiby (1997) defines it as "invisible assets that include employee competence, internal structure and external structure."
  • Sullivan (1998) defines it as "Knowledge that can be converted into profits".
  • The Konrad Grop (1998) refers to it as "know-how capital"
  • Viedma (1999) defines it as "equal to a company's core competencies"
  • Kaplan and Norton (2001) use the term intangible assets, which they define as the skills, competencies and motivation of employees; databases and information technologies; efficient and responsive operating processes; innovation in products and services; customer loyalty and relationships; and political, regulatory and social approval.

Perhaps all the definitions together does convey the correct picture to the reader. To be sure, IC Tracker has put together the following picture to make the meaning of Intellectual Capital absolutely clear to its users.

Intellectual Capital explained

In the above picture, a company's capital is depicted from both an internal and an external perspective. Looking at the internal perspective, we can see that the assets that are listed on the balance sheet include the tangible assets(land, plant and equipment, etc.) and intangible assets(Sofware, Goodwill, etc.). The Book Value of the company's share is computed by dividing the Net Worth of the company by the total number of shares outstanding. Thus the balance sheet of the company can be used only for computing the Book Value of the company's shares. Clearly, the book value of the company does not account for any of the intangible assets of the company. Hence it is inadequate for knowing the true worth of the company. If we depict all the intangible capital of the company as "Intellectual Capital" as shown in the picture, and add it to the Net Worth, we reach a value which can be called the Intrinsic Worth of the company. The Intrinsic Worth of a company better reflects its true value, and is very close to the Market Value of the comany as shown in the extternal perspctive.

Back to Top of the Page

2.2 Net Worth

Net Worth refers to the value of the company as carried on its books. It is determined by subtracting liabilities on the balance sheet from the assets. It is also know as the owner's equity and equals the paid-up share capital plus the reserves on the company's books of accounts. The Net Worth of the company seldom reflects its true worth, as refelcted by the fact that the Market Cap of most companies is a multiple of its Net Worth.
Back to Top of the Page

2.3 Market Cap

Market Cap refers to the total market value of all of a company's outstanding shares. It is determined by multiplying a company's outstanding shares by the current market price of one share. Investors typically use this number to determine a company's size. ICTracker uses the Actual Stock Price and the latest available outstanding shares figure for determining the market cap of the company. This ensures that the Intrinsic Worth of the company is compared against the Market Cap on (nearabouts) the same date, thus making the comparison highly meaninghful. Since the share price of the company fluctuates hevaily during trading hours, the market cap of the company fluctuates accordingly.
Back to Top of the Page

2.4 Intrinsic Worth

Intrinsic Worth refers to the true value of a company. It is determined by adding the Intellectual Capital to the Net Worth of the company.
Back to Top of the Page

2.5 Long Term Growth

Long Term Growth refers to the expected Long term grorth rate of the company in question, typically the growth rate after the 10th year. This rate should be influenced by the maturity of the Company as well as the Industry that it operates in. For e.g New companies in new industries should clock high growth rates while mature companies in mature industries should clock relatively low growth rates. IC Tracker assigns a default growth rate to every company based on the available broker research, ehich if not available, it defaults to a growth rate of 6%. Since this growth rate can be subjective, IC Tracker allows the user to change the Long term Growth rate manually and recalculate the Intellectual Capital of the Company with the new Growth rate.
Back to Top of the Page

2.6 Discount Rate

Discount Rate refers to the earnings rate used in calculating the present value of future cash flows using the discounting process. By default, IC Tracker uses the Weighted Average Cost of Capital of the Company (as calculated from data available from its latest financial statements) as the Discount Rate. Since this default discount rate can be subjective, IC Tracker allows the user to change the Discount rate manualy and recalculate the Intellectual Capital of the Company with the new Discount rate.
Back to Top of the Page

2.7 Liquidity Premium

Liquidity Premium refers to a percentage that reflects how liquid a company's stock is compared to another stock. In general, the assumption here is that the liquidity of a stock is direclty proportional to the free-float percentage. Free-float refers to the percentage of the company's shares that are available in the stock market for trading. It is calculated by deducting the locked-in shares, such as those held by promoters and Govermnent Institutions, from the total otustanding shares of the company. By default, IC Tracker sets the Liquidity Premium of the Company as 1/10th of its Free Float percentage(as calculated from data available from its latest financial statements or from data published by Stock Exchanges). Since this Liquidity Premium rate can be subjective, IC Tracker allows the user to change the Liquidity Premium rate manually. Liquidity Premium does not have any effect on the IC calculation. It is used only for discounting the Actual Stock Price and the Closing Stock Price for a more realistic comparison of these values with the Intrinsic Stock Price.
Back to Top of the Page

2.8 MVToIV

MVToIV refers to the ratio of the Market Cap to the Intrinsic Worth of the Company. A value of greater than 1 indicates that the company's stock is overvalued whereas a value of less than 1 indicates that the company's stock is undervalued. Note that since Intellectual Capital, as calculated by ICTracker, is relevant as of a specific date (typically the Quarter end date), the MVToIV ratio is also relevant as of the same date.
Back to Top of the Page

2.9 K Basis

K Basis refers to the Knowledge Basis of the Company. It is computed by dividing the Intellectual Capital of the company by its Net Worth. The K Basis is a very important ratio, since it can be used to determine which company is relatively more knowlegde based within the same Industry. A higher value of K Basis indicates that the company is more knowledge based and a lower value indicates that it is less knowledge based.
Back to Top of the Page

2.10 IC Margin

IC Margin is short for the Intellectual Capital Margin of the Company. It is computed by dividing the Intellectual Capital by the average anuual Sales (both past and Forecasted) of the Company. A high value of IC Margin indicates that the Intellectual Capital of the company is not contributing to Sales - hence everything else being equal a low value of IC Margin is desirable.
Back to Top of the Page

2.11 IC Op Margin

IC Op Margin is short for the Intellectual Capital Operating Margin of the Company. It is computed by dividing the Intellectual Capital by the average anuual EBITDA (both past and Forecasted) of the Company. A high value of IC Op Margin indicates that the Intellectual Capital of the company is not contributing to Operating Profits - hence everything else being equal a low value of IC Op Margin is desirable.
Back to Top of the Page

2.12 Intrinsic Stock Price

Intrinsic Stock Price is determined by dividing the Intrinsic Worth of the company by the total number of shares outstanding. It reflects the true price of the company's stock as of the date that the Intrinsic Worth is calculated. The Intrinsic Stock Price can therefore be compared to the Actual Stock Price of the company to determine whether the stock is undervalue or overvalued.
Back to Top of the Page

2.13 Actual Stock Price

Actual Stock Price refers to the closing market price of the company's stock as of the date that the Intrinsic Worth of the Company is calculated. Typically, this date is one of the four quarter-end dates during the year. IC Tracker reports both the actual value of the stock price on this date as well as the price discounted for Liquidity Premium.
Back to Top of the Page.

2.14 Latest Stock Price

Latest Stock Price refers to the latest available closing market price of the company's stock. IC Tracker reports both the actual value of the stock price as well as the price discounted for Liquidity Premium.
Back to Top of the Page

2.15 Past Financials

Past Financials refers the publicly available historical financial information of the company. Typically, companies publish quarterly income updates and a annual balance sheet. IC Tracker uses the past 12 quarters of income data for calculating the Intellectual Capital of the company using the Intellectual Capital Valuation Methodology.
Back to Top of the Page

2.16 Forecasted Financials

IC Tracker uses the Past Financials to forecast the income data for the next 12 quarters. Refer FAQ 4.2 to understand how IC Tracker generates the forecast data. The forecasted financials are then used along with the Past Financials for calculating the Intellectual Capital of the company using the Intellectual Capital Valuation Methodology. This works very well except for the following 2 exceptions:

  • Exception 1: Sometimes the Past Financials of a company in question is not available, perhaps because the company is listed but has not yet commenced operations. In such cases, the Financial Forecast cannot be generated. Hence the Intellectucal Capital of such companies cannot be calculated either.
  • Exception 2: More frequently, it is found that the past financials of the company in question is available for less than the required 12 quarters, because the company is relatively new. In this case, IC Tracker goes ahead and generates the Financial Forecast for the sake of completeness, however the lack of sufficient past data impacts the robustness of Intellectual Capital calculations. Hence users are advised to always check the quantum of past financials available for the company in question before using the calculation results.  

  • Back to Top of the Page

    2.17 Sales

    In accounting parlance, Sales is defined as the revenue obtained from each recorded incidence of a sale of goods and/or services as recognized in the accounting system. Income from Sales normally contributes to the bulk of the Total Income of a company.
    Back to Top of the Page

    2.18 Total Income

    Total Income or "Gross Income" is computed by adding together Sales revenues and Other Income, which typically includes Interest Income, Rental Income, etc.
    Back to Top of the Page

    2.19 EBITDA

    EBITDA is short for "Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization". It is calculated by deducting operating expenses from Total Income. In other words tax, interest expense, depreciation and amortization expenses are not deducted when calculating EBITDA. Hence this measure reflects the operational profit of the company since it leaves out the effect of financing and accounting decisions. Typically, investors needs to use this measure along with other financial performance measures to arrive at a true picture of financial performance of the company.
    Back to Top of the Page

    2.20 PBDT

    PBDT is short for "Profit Before Depreciation and Tax". It is calculated by deducting Interest expenses from EBITDA.
    Back to Top of the Page

    2.21 PBT

    PBT is short for "Profit Before Tax". This is a measure that can be used to look at the company's profits before it has to pay corporate taxes. It is also sometimes referred to as "Earnings Before Tax". It is calculated by deducting all expenses from Total Income including operating expenses, interest and depreciation expensess, but leaving out the payment of tax. This measure is useful because tax expense is constantly changing and taking it out helps to give an investor a good idea of changes in a company's profits from year to year.
    Back to Top of the Page

    2.22 PAT

    PAT is short for "Profit After Tax". It is also sometimes referred to as "Net Income". It is calculated by starting with the company's total revenue. From this the cost of sales, along with other financial expenses such as interest, depreciation and amortization is removed to arrive at Profit Before Tax. Tax is then deducted from this number to reach the PAT number. This number is found in the company's income statement and is an important measure of how profitable the company is over a period of time. This measure is also used to calculate Earnings Per Share. It is often referred to as "the bottom line".
    Back to Top of the Page



    3.0 Intellectual Capital Valuation Methodology


    The IC Valuation methodology usedby IC Tracker uses the Intangible Scorecard approach formulated by Lev and Gu (2002). The scorecard calculates earnings created by intangible assets and it uses these Intangible Derived Earnings (IDEs) to calculate Intellectual Capital. The method starts by looking at company earnings, based on an average of 12 quarters of hisrtorical earnings data and another 12 quarters of forecasted earnings. The result is an estimate of annual normalized earnings. From these earnings, the the expected rates of return on physical assets and financial assets is deducted at 7% and 4.5% respectively at the latest available book value of these assets. This results in current IDE. Next the future IDEs for the next 10 years are forecasted using an appropriate Discount Rate and Long Term Growth Rate. For years, 11 to infinity the earnings are converged into the long term growth rate of the economy, which is set to 5% for the Indian economy. Summing up these IDEs produces the Net Present Value of the Intellectual Capital of the Company.
    Back to Top of the Page


    4.0 FAQ

    1. What is the difference between Intellectual Capital, Intangible Capital and Intangible Assets?
    2. How does IC Tracker determine the future Financials of the Company?
    3. What about companies whose financial data is not available?
    4.1 What is the difference between Intellectual Capital, Intangible Capital and Intangible Assets?

    All three refer to the same thing which is Intellectual Capital. However different authors refer to this term using any one of these three terms, hence the confusion. It is compounded by the fact that Intangible Assets is defined in the Accounting world by the Accounting Standards Board as "an identifiable non-monetary asset without physical substance held for use in the production of suppy of goods or services, for rental to others, or for administrative purposes." An asset is defined in the accounting world as "a resource controlled by an enterprise as a result of past events and from which future economic benefits are expected to flow to the enterprise." Therefore, an intangible asset needs to be identifiable, must have an owner and must be able to generate future income. Clearly the Accounting world's view of Intangible Assets is much narrower than the concept of Intellectual Capital. Hence IC Tracker avoids using Intangible Assets altogether to refer to Intellectual Capital, in order to avoid general confusion.
    Back to Top of the Page

    4.2 How does IC Tracker determine the future Financials of the Company?

    IC Tracker generates the future financials of the company in one of two different ways.

    Where Broker Research is available for the company in question, IC Tracker uses such research to generate the financial forecast for the next three years. For the next seven years and also where Broker Rearch is not available, IC Tracker uses linear regression to predict future financials. Admittedly, these forecasts will not be accurate, however the calculcation methodology uses the Average Earnings numbers of both the past and the present which lessens the error present in the forecast.
    Back to Top of the Page

    4.3 What about companies whose financial data is not available?

    Many a time the past financial of a company is not available, perhaps because the company may not yet have commenced operations. In such cases, IC Tracker is unable to generate the Financial Forecast as well. Consequently, the Intellecutal Capital of such companies cannot be calculated.
    Back to Top of the Page